The upright bass was the instrument the electric bass was meant to replace. Upright basses are large and less hardy than solid body instruments. They needed to be large in order to produce bass frequencies at volumes a listener could hear along side other acoustic instruments. The upright bass had a hard time competing with the volume of drum sets and electric guitars. A new instrument was needed to go with the new music being played that used these instruments. There were several instruments invented in the decades preceding Leo Fenders release of the Precision Bass. There were attempts to amplify upright basses. Reliability and ease of portability won out in the end. The instrument recreated the low end of the upright bass but had the addition of frets. Frets are small pieces of metal wire attached to the fingerboard of strung instruments at each note. Upright basses didn’t have frets. The musician held the string directly to the fingerboard to produce the desired pitch and being in tune was up to him. Frets made it easier for guitarists to transition to electric bass in the early years as well.
Something was missing.
Electric bass guitars and upright basses have notes that fall in the same register, but the tones are different. It’s not impossible to comp the sound of an upright bass on an electric bass guitar. Having frets on the neck of a bass guitar makes this attempt a little more difficult.
Legend has it that jazz great Jaco Pastorius had an upright bass that fell apart in the humid Florida climate. Instead of getting it fixed, he grabbed his pliers and removed the frets from his electric Fender Jazz Bass guitar and the fretless bass was born. While Jaco’s contribution to fretless playing is undeniable, he didn’t invent it. Companies like Gibson and Ampeg were putting out fretless versions almost from the beginning. The recipe of playability and sound wasn’t right at the time.
Fretless bass guitars are very expressive instruments. Many bassists are intimidated by the lack of frets. Like all things in life, practice will fix that. In this case, ear practice is what’s necessary. Placing your finger in the exact right place comes from repetition of the hand but tilting your finger forward or back to make the micro-tonal adjustments necessary for correct pitch happens with ear training. Almost anyone can do it with practice. Tone deafness is extremely rare. I find that that fretless goes great with acoustic guitars, pianos and ballads. The decreased attack of a fretless tends to get muddled when placed opposite overdriven guitars. That’s certainly not a rule, as evidenced by Les Claypool. Fretless is a great option in the studio. It’s good to have as many colors on your palette as you can.